Can I challenge a lien or easement on a
property?
Think you can wipe out a lien or easement on your property? Here’s the fast, practical roadmap that actually works.
Quick answer
Yes. You can challenge a lien or an easement, but the path, cost, and likelihood of success depend on documentation, timing, and legal grounds. This guide gives clear steps, common defenses, and exactly when to escalate to court.
Why this matters
A lien or easement is an encumbrance on your title. It can block a sale, lower value, limit use, or create liability. Treat it like a medical emergency for your property: diagnose fast, act precisely.
What a lien and an easement are
- Lien: A legal claim against property to secure payment (tax lien, mortgage, construction lien).
- Easement: A right for someone to use part of your property (utility, access, prescriptive).
Keywords: challenge a lien, challenge an easement, property lien, contest easement, quiet title, title dispute.
How to challenge a lien — step by step
- Pull the public records: deed, title report, recorded lien document, chain of title. Confirm the lien’s recording date and claimant.
- Check validity: Was the lien properly recorded? Is the claimant named correctly? Are signatures notarized?
- Confirm statute of limitations: Many liens expire or become unenforceable after a set time.
- Use title insurance: If you have a title policy, file a claim. Title companies often clear defects faster than courts.
- Negotiate or demand release: If the debt was paid or invalid, demand a lien discharge. Consider paying under a reservation if it clears the title now.
- File a quiet title or lien discharge action: If negotiation fails, a court can remove improper liens.
How to challenge an easement — step by step
- Review the recorded easement document and survey what it actually allows.
- Check for defects: Was it granted by someone without authority? Was notice or permission required but not given?
- Look for abandonment or non-use: Long-term non-use or changed conditions may let you terminate a prescriptive easement.
- Consider relocation: For utility easements, negotiate relocation or compensation.
- File an action to quiet title or terminate/eject: Courts can limit, modify or extinguish easements based on evidence.
Common defenses and evidence that win cases
- Improper or fraudulent recording
- Lack of notice to property owner
- Paid or satisfied debt with missing discharge
- Statute of limitations expired
- Abandonment or changed circumstances for easements
- Title insurance coverage
When to hire a lawyer
If the lien or easement threatens sale, financing, or use, hire a real estate attorney. Complex claims, forged documents, or adverse possession fights need counsel.
Next steps (action checklist)
- Order a current title search and property survey
- Gather contracts, invoices, closing statements, and correspondence
- Contact your title insurance provider
- Consult a specialized real estate lawyer
Tony Sousa is a local realtor and property title authority. For a practical assessment and next steps, contact Tony: tony@sousasells.ca | 416-477-2620 | https://www.sousasells.ca
Act now: clear your title, protect value, and get the property back to marketable condition.
