How do I handle a failed closing?
“Closing fell apart—now what?” — Learn the exact steps that turn a failed closing into your win, not your loss.
You can still control this
A failed closing is a blow. But in Milton‘s busy market, a well-handled failure becomes a reset button — not a catastrophe. Read this quick, practical plan and follow the steps in order. This is written for Milton home sellers who want clear, legal, and market-smart moves to protect money, time, and sanity.
Why closings fail (keep this short)
- Buyer financing falls through.
- Title problems or outstanding liens.
- Buyer changes mind after waiving conditions.
- Inspection or disclosure disputes.
- Missing signatures, wrong dates, or administrative errors.
In Milton and across Ontario, the paperwork rules matter more than emotions. The Agreement of Purchase and Sale (often the OREA standard form) and the specific clauses inside it decide what you can do next.
First 24 hours: stop guessing, take action
- Breathe. Then call your lawyer and your listing agent immediately.
- Confirm the exact breach in writing. Who missed what? When was a condition waived? Get dates and references to the APS clauses.
- Preserve the deposit. In Ontario, deposits are held in trust by the listing brokerage or lawyer. Don’t let it be released without a legal agreement.
- Document everything. Save emails, text messages, and notes from calls. This creates a timeline you will need for RECO, court, or mediation.
Do these first four things and you’ve already turned panic into control.
Legal basics every Milton seller should know
- REBBA 2002 and RECO: Real estate trading in Ontario is governed by the Real Estate and Business Brokers Act (REBBA) and enforced by the Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO). If your brokerage mishandles deposit trust obligations, you can file a complaint.
- Agreement controls: The OREA Agreement of Purchase and Sale or your custom APS controls remedies, notice requirements, and timeframes.
- Deposits are trust funds: Brokerages must follow strict trust accounting rules. If there’s a deposit dispute, the brokerage can hold funds until parties agree or a court/order decides.
- Time is of the essence: If the APS includes a “time is of the essence” clause, deadlines become critical. Missing them can change your remedies.
- Remedies: Typical remedies include retaining deposit, suing for damages, or applying for specific performance. Specific performance (forcing the buyer to complete) is possible in Ontario, but courts apply it selectively.
Practical legal options — what works in Milton now
-
Accept termination and keep the deposit (when permitted). If the buyer defaults after conditions are removed and the APS allows it, you may be entitled to keep the deposit and terminate. This is the fastest cash outcome.
-
Give notice to the buyer and cure period. Some agreements require a written notice and a short period to remedy. Follow the APS exactly. If a technical notice is missed, you may lose rights.
-
Sue for damages. If you kept the deposit but lost value on a re-sale, you can pursue the buyer for the shortfall and related losses. This is common when markets change and you re-sell for less.
-
Specific performance. This forces the buyer to close. It’s powerful but unpredictable. Courts consider fairness and whether monetary damages are adequate. Use it when the property is unique or the loss would be severe.
-
Mediation or arbitration. Many disputes settle here faster and cheaper than court. If the APS provides for alternative dispute resolution, use it.
How to mitigate losses in Milton’s market
- Re-list fast but smart. Price aggressively based on current comps and the reason the first deal failed.
- Short-term rental or hold-over plan. If the sale falls through close to move day, you may need temporary housing or rental income. Plan ahead.
- Fix title issues with your lawyer immediately. Delays on title searches and lien clearances are fixable and often quick with the right counsel.
- Control narrative for buyers and agents. Be professional. State facts, dates, and your readiness to re-list or negotiate. Reputation matters in a tight market like Milton.
Communication: what to say and what not to say
Say: “We are following the APS terms and working with our lawyer. The deposit remains in trust pending legal resolution.”
Don’t say: “No big deal” or confess anything that looks like admission of wrongdoing. Avoid unnecessary apologies or detailed public explanations.
Timeline example: realistic expectations
- Day 0–1: Confirm breach, call lawyer, put documentation in order.
- Day 1–3: Lawyer issues formal notice to buyer’s counsel or brokerage.
- Day 3–14: Negotiation or cure period. Mediation may begin.
- Day 14–60: If unresolved, prepare for litigation or re-list.
This timeline depends on the clause language and whether the buyer responds.
When to keep the deposit — a checklist
- The buyer waived all conditions and missed closing.
- The APS allows seller to terminate and keep deposit on default.
- Your lawyer confirms holding the deposit is appropriate under the facts.
If you tick these boxes, keeping the deposit is often the right immediate move. But understand it doesn’t automatically prevent further legal action by the buyer.
When to consider specific performance
- The buyer is clearly at fault and refuses to close.
- The property is unique or market conditions make money damages inadequate.
- You can show a court that monetary damages won’t make you whole.
Note: Courts in Ontario grant specific performance selectively. Talk to a real estate litigator before filing.
Avoid these myths
- Myth: “Keeping the deposit solves everything.” No. It may not cover the full loss on re-sale or legal fees.
- Myth: “I can re-sell immediately at the same price.” Market moves. Prep for variable outcomes.
- Myth: “RECO will fix my problem fast.” RECO handles conduct complaints, not contract enforcement. Use RECO for brokerage misconduct, not to force a buyer to close.
Negotiation moves that work
- Offer an extension for a fee: If the buyer wants more time, charge reasonable compensation for delay.
- Convert default into a new deal: If the buyer’s financing is a problem, negotiate new terms — maybe a larger deposit, different closing date, or cash-back.
- Partial release of deposit for quick settlement: Some sellers accept a portion of the deposit and a release from the buyer to avoid litigation.
Why local expertise matters
Milton is part of Halton Region and the Greater Toronto market. Inventory levels, buyer demand, and average days on market all affect how quickly you can re-list and at what price. Local lawyers, agents, and title companies know which title and municipal quirks cause delays here. Use them.
Final, practical checklist for a failed closing in Milton
- Step 1: Call your lawyer and your listing agent now.
- Step 2: Confirm breach and preserve the deposit.
- Step 3: Send formal notice per the APS.
- Step 4: Mitigate losses — re-list, repair, or rent if needed.
- Step 5: Decide: negotiate, accept termination, sue, or seek specific performance.
Do these steps in order and you control the outcome.
Authoritative help (direct, local)
If you’re a Milton seller facing a failed closing, don’t guess. Call a local agent who understands REBBA, RECO, and the OREA APS inside out. If you want straightforward, local help and fast action, reach out:
Tony Sousa, Milton Realtor
Email: tony@sousasells.ca
Phone: 416-477-2620
Web: https://www.sousasells.ca
You’ll get a direct plan, a local market read, and a lawyer referral if needed.
FAQ — Everything Milton sellers ask about failed closings
Q: Can the buyer get their deposit back if they failed to close?
A: It depends. If the buyer defaulted after waiving conditions and the APS gives the seller the right to keep the deposit, the buyer likely loses it. If the buyer defaulted for reasons covered by a condition (financing not waived), they may recover the deposit. Disputes over deposit splits often end in negotiation or court.
Q: How long before I have to re-list the property?
A: Re-list when you have your documents and keys back and the deposit issue is clear. Practically, once the buyer is formally terminated or you have a clear path to terminate, re-list immediately. In Milton’s market, quick relists often attract strong interest.
Q: Will I have to pay more legal fees if I sue?
A: Yes. Litigation raises costs. That’s why mediation or settlement is common. Discuss cost-benefit with your lawyer before suing for shortfall.
Q: Can I force the buyer to close if they backed out?
A: You can apply for specific performance in Ontario. Courts grant it selectively. It helps when the property is unique or the financial loss is not easily measured.
Q: Who enforces deposit trust rules in Ontario?
A: The Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO) oversees brokerage conduct related to trust funds. RECO can discipline brokerages for trust failures, but it won’t decide contract disputes between buyers and sellers — that’s a court matter.
Q: What local laws in Milton affect closings?
A: Ontario rules apply: REBBA 2002, OREA APS forms, Land Transfer Tax rules, and municipal title or zoning items from Halton Region or the Town of Milton that show on title searches. Your lawyer will clear municipal requirements before closing.
Q: How do I choose the right lawyer?
A: Pick a lawyer experienced in Ontario residential closings and title issues. Local Milton or Halton lawyers know municipal quirks and speed up issue resolution. Ask for references or a quick consult.
Q: Can I list with a new agent right away?
A: Yes, but check any existing brokerage agreements and timing. If your listing agreement expired or you’ve legally terminated the transaction, you can re-list. If unsure, consult your lawyer and your agent.
If you want a one-page playbook tailored to your property and the exact clause language in your APS, reach out. This is not an abstract debate—this is money, timelines, and your next move. Call Tony at 416-477-2620 or email tony@sousasells.ca.
