Can I negotiate after accepting an offer?
Think you can change the deal after you said “yes”? Here’s exactly when you can — and how to do it safely as a Milton home seller.
Quick answer: Can I negotiate after accepting an offer?
Short answer: Yes — but only if the buyer agrees. In Ontario, a signed and accepted offer is a legal contract. You can propose changes, but you cannot force them. Attempting unilateral changes can lead to a breach of contract, a demand for performance, or a lawsuit. The smart move: negotiate with the buyer through formal written amendments, leverage what you have (deposit, timelines, market demand), and get your lawyer or agent to document everything.
Why acceptance matters under Ontario law
When you and the buyer both sign and initial an Agreement of Purchase and Sale, you create a binding contract. That contract sets price, closing date, conditions (subjects), deposit details, chattels included, and more. In Ontario real estate practice:
- An accepted offer is legally enforceable. Both sides have duties.
- Conditions (like financing or inspection) give the buyer limited rights to void the deal within the condition timeline.
- If either party wants to change terms, the other party must agree in writing. Otherwise, it’s a breach.
For a Milton seller, that legal certainty matters. Buyers here are often commuters to Toronto and can walk away if terms shift unfavorably. That’s why renegotiation must be tight, clear, and documented.
When you can (and commonly will) negotiate after acceptance
You don’t have to panic if something better or worse appears after acceptance. Common situations that trigger renegotiation include:
- A higher competing offer arrives.
- Buyer requests repairs after an inspection.
- Closing date or possession needs to change.
- Financing problems surface on the buyer’s end.
- Seller discovers information they didn’t disclose and needs to amend the contract.
In each case, the route is the same: propose an amendment, get the buyer’s written consent, and update the deposit or conditions if needed.
Practical negotiation moves that work in Milton’s market
Milton’s market has been tight in recent years — low inventory, solid buyer demand, and many buyers commuting to the GTA. That changes leverage. Be direct and pick the tactic that suits your position:
- Ask for more deposit instead of raising price: Buyers resist price increases, but a larger deposit shows commitment.
- Offer a small credit for repairs instead of fixing everything: Faster, cleaner, and keeps the transaction moving.
- Trade closing date flexibility for money: If buyer wants a quick close, require a price or deposit concession.
- Convert vague requests into time-limited written offers: Set a deadline to force a yes/no.
- Use other offers as leverage carefully: Notify the buyer you have another offer and give them a short window to match. Never invent or fake offers.
All of these must be done through written amendments to the accepted Agreement of Purchase and Sale.
Step-by-step: How to renegotiate after acceptance without legal risk
- Stop communicating verbally. Move everything to email or formal amendment forms.
- Talk to your listing agent and lawyer immediately. They’ll draft the correct amendment.
- Make a clear proposal. State what you want changed and what you offer in return (money, dates, deposit).
- Give the buyer a deadline. Short, firm deadlines get answers.
- If the buyer refuses, decide: proceed on original terms or terminate only if a condition allows.
- If buyer accepts, ensure both parties sign the amendment and funds (if any) are handled properly.
Important: Don’t accept a buyer’s verbal nod. Get initials, signatures, and updated deposit receipts. Without the paperwork, you’re exposing yourself to risk.
How inspections, financing, and subjects affect renegotiation
-
Inspections: If the buyer’s inspector finds problems, the buyer may request repairs or credit. You can agree, refuse, or counter. If the buyer’s subject removal deadline arrives and they’ve waived the subject, they can’t later demand changes.
-
Financing: If a buyer can’t secure financing within the conditional period, they can rely on that subject to void the deal. You can request proof of mortgage effort earlier in the process.
-
Chattels/Fixtures: Mistakes happen. If you forgot to include an item, you can offer an amendment for a credit or return it before closing.
Timing matters. Most renegotiations succeed when handled fast and with a clear trade-off.
Real examples Milton sellers need to know
Example 1: A higher offer arrives after you’ve accepted. You can present it to the buyer and ask them to match or improve. If they refuse, you cannot simply accept the new offer unless the buyer agrees to release you in writing or you pursue termination under a valid condition.
Example 2: Inspection shows a cracked foundation. Buyer asks for $10,000 credit. You offer $5,000 and ask for a limited warranty. Buyer accepts and signs an amendment. Sale stays alive.
Example 3: Buyer asks to push closing 30 days later. You ask for a $2,000 non-refundable extension deposit. Buyer agrees, signs amendment, and sends funds.
Each example shows the same rule: change only with signed agreement.
Scripts that work — what to say, exactly
- To buyer’s agent: “Buyer, we want to keep this deal. We need X changed. Our change: Y in return. Please confirm in writing by [date/time].”
- To buyer directly: “We’re prepared to [repair/credit/change closing]. We need written confirmation and an updated deposit by [date].”
- If buyer stalls: “Without a signed amendment by [time], we will expect performance under the original agreement or pursue other options.”
Be firm. Be clear. Don’t negotiate under pressure without a documented trade.
Why Milton sellers have to move fast
Milton is part of the Greater Toronto Area commuter belt. Buyers here often have multiple options. A slow or messy renegotiation loses momentum and can lead buyers to walk. Fast, clean, and documented trade-offs preserve the sale and protect you legally.
Also, local market quirks matter: seasonal demand, school-year moves, and commuting timelines. Use them. If your buyer needs to move for a job in Toronto, leverage the timeline for better terms.
What to avoid at all costs
- Don’t change terms without written consent.
- Don’t assume verbal promises are enforceable.
- Don’t delay getting legal advice if the buyer claims a condition allows cancellation.
- Don’t misrepresent the presence of competing offers.
Breaking these rules risks damage claims, deposit disputes, and failed closings.
Final checklist for renegotiating after an accepted offer
- Consult your lawyer and agent immediately.
- Draft a clear, written amendment with deadlines.
- Ask for compensation or value in return for any concession.
- Get signatures and updated deposit receipts.
- Keep communication factual, brief, and documented.
Milton market edge: when to push and when to accept
If inventory is low and demand is high, you have leverage. Push for more deposit, better closing terms, or credits in exchange for changes. If the market softens or the buyer has strong leverage (conditional approvals, financing delays), accept practical fixes that preserve the deal.
Good negotiators adapt to the market. Don’t let emotions drive decisions. Use data: recent comparable sales, time on market, and local demand trends.
Call to action — get expert representation
If you’re a home seller in Milton and face a renegotiation after accepting an offer, don’t guess. Get experienced help. Tony Sousa is a Milton realtor who handles offers and negotiation every day. He will: analyze risk, draft amendment language, and negotiate clear value in return.
Reach out: tony@sousasells.ca | 416-477-2620 | https://www.sousasells.ca
FAQ — Offers & negotiation for Milton home sellers
Q: Is an accepted offer binding in Ontario?
A: Yes. A signed Agreement of Purchase and Sale is legally binding. Changes require both parties’ written consent.
Q: Can I accept a new higher offer after I’ve already accepted one?
A: Not without written release from the first buyer or their agreement to the new terms. Otherwise you risk breach of contract.
Q: Can I ask for more money after acceptance?
A: You can propose it, but the buyer must agree. Consider asking for more deposit or offering a credit instead of a price increase.
Q: What if the buyer fails a financing condition?
A: If they can’t remove the financing condition within the timeline, the buyer may void the deal. You can request proof of mortgage efforts earlier, but you can’t force financing.
Q: What if an inspection reveals major issues?
A: The buyer will request repairs or credit. You can negotiate a lesser credit, provide repair receipts, or stand firm. If the buyer waives the inspection subject, they generally can’t come back later.
Q: How do I document changes?
A: Use a formal written amendment to the Agreement of Purchase and Sale. Both parties must sign. Get updated deposit receipts where applicable.
Q: What happens if the buyer refuses my amendment?
A: The contract remains as-is. You must either proceed under original terms or pursue termination only if a valid subject permits.
Q: Can I get out if I find a better offer?
A: Only if the buyer agrees to release you in writing, or if a valid condition allows termination. Otherwise, you’re bound and could face damages.
Q: Should I consult a lawyer?
A: Always consult a real estate lawyer when renegotiating accepted terms, especially on large changes (price, deposit, closing dates) or disputes.
Q: How fast should I act?
A: Immediately. Delay increases risk. Present a written amendment, set a tight deadline, and involve your agent and lawyer.
If you want direct help navigating a renegotiation in Milton, contact Tony Sousa at tony@sousasells.ca or 416-477-2620. He knows local buyers, local timelines, and how to close deals cleanly in Milton’s market.
Note: This article is for informational purposes and does not replace legal advice. For contract-specific questions, talk to your lawyer.
