Can I negotiate after a home inspection?
Can you reopen negotiations after a home inspection? Yes — and if you’re a seller in Georgetown, Ontario, here’s exactly how to turn that inspection into leverage instead of a liability.
Quick answer: You can negotiate after a home inspection
Short version: Yes. A home inspection often triggers a negotiation window. Buyers typically request repairs, credits, or price reductions based on inspection findings. Sellers can accept, refuse, counteroffer, or fix items themselves. The key is speed, clarity, and strategy.
This post tells you what to do step-by-step, gives scripts you can use, explains legal and timing issues in Ontario, and shows how sellers in Georgetown get the best outcome without losing their sale.
Why this matters in Georgetown, ON
Georgetown is part of Halton Hills. The local market is competitive, but many buyers still include inspection conditions. That means inspections are negotiation events, not surprises. If you’re selling here, you need a clear playbook so a buyer’s inspection report doesn’t derail closing or force unnecessary concessions.
What the buyer’s inspection actually does
- Confirms condition and uncovers defects.
- Gives the buyer grounds to ask for repairs, credits, or to walk away if the agreement is conditional on inspection.
- Shifts bargaining power temporarily to the buyer — if the buyer can credibly cancel.
If you understand those outcomes, you control the response.
The seller’s options after an inspection
- Accept repair requests and arrange the work.
- Offer a cash credit at closing instead of repairs.
- Offer a partial price reduction and move on.
- Refuse and stand your ground.
- Negotiate a middle ground (e.g., fix critical items, credit minor items).
- Cancel the sale only if buyer exercises the right to cancel — sellers can’t unilaterally cancel based on an inspection unless the contract allows.
Choose based on cost, market dynamics, and timeline.
How to evaluate repair requests fast (use this checklist)
- Is it a safety issue? (electrical hazards, structural problems) — prioritize fixing.
- Is it a major system failure? (roof, HVAC, foundation) — evaluate repair vs credit.
- Cosmetic issues? (peeling paint, minor cracks) — usually not worth full repair responsibility.
- Cost to fix vs impact on sale: compare repair cost to likely price reduction.
- Get at least one contractor quote immediately for any item over $1,000.
If the cost to repair is less than the likely drop in buyer appetite or a negotiated credit — fix it.
Timing and legal steps in Ontario (what sellers must know)
- Most offers in Ontario include an inspection condition with a deadline. The buyer must notify the seller by that deadline if they want changes or to waive the condition.
- If the buyer cancels properly within the condition deadline, the deposit is typically returned and the transaction ends.
- If the buyer asks for repairs or credits by the deadline, the seller can respond with a written counter-offer. Silence is not acceptance.
- Everything must be documented in writing through your Realtor and added to the Agreement of Purchase and Sale.
- Always consult your lawyer for complex structural or legal items.
Step-by-step negotiation playbook for sellers (actionable)
- Read the inspection report immediately. Highlight safety and major systems.
- Respond inside the condition deadline. Delays kill leverage.
- Get contractor quotes for major items the same day or next business day.
- Decide: repair, credit, or decline. Use cost vs. sale-risk math.
- Ask your agent to draft a concise counter: accept X repairs, offer $Y credit, or decline.
- Use a deadline in your counter-offer — 24–48 hours to respond keeps momentum.
- If buyer pushes, escalate strategically: show proof of contractor quotes, explain market context, or offer a small concession to close.
Scripts sellers can use (copy/paste)
-
If you’ll fix: “We will complete the following repairs before closing: [list]. Work will be done by licensed contractors. If scheduling requires an adjustment to closing, we will notify you in writing.”
-
If you prefer a credit: “Rather than arranging repairs, we will provide a credit of $X at closing to cover the buyer’s agreed inspection items.”
-
If you decline: “Based on our review and contractor estimates, we will not be making additional repairs. The home is being sold as inspected and priced accordingly.”
Use your agent to send these professionally.
Pricing strategy: when to give money vs. fix
- If repair cost < 1% of sale price and it’s a clear fix, repair it. Buyers feel reassured.
- For costs between 1–3%, consider a credit. It’s often simpler and avoids scheduling delays.
- Over 3–4%, treat as major renegotiation — evaluate market strength. In a seller’s market you can often refuse; in a buyer’s market you may need to concede.
Adjust percentages based on local Georgetown market conditions and comparable sales. Your Realtor should advise.
How to keep buyers from overreaching
- Require evidence. Ask for specific defect items, not vague statements.
- Counter with contractor quotes or third-party opinions.
- Keep communications factual: dates, costs, quotes, and scope.
- Don’t accept broad “repair everything” demands. Narrow the request.
Common buyer requests and ideal seller responses
- Roof leaks: fix or offer a credit if roof replacement is imminent.
- Electrical concerns: prioritize licensed electrician repairs.
- HVAC issues: service and provide receipts; offer credit for major replacement.
- Structural concerns: get an engineer’s note before agreeing to anything large.
Local tip: Georgetown inspection realities
- Older homes in Georgetown may show dated systems. Expect buyers to flag older furnaces, electrical panels, and roofs.
- Supply chain and contractor availability can affect repair timing. Get quotes fast.
- Buyers moving from bigger cities may expect turnkey homes. Offer small credits and a clear repair plan to keep them confident.
Negotiation mindset — be direct, not defensive
Keep the tone firm and practical. Don’t apologize for age or wear. Present facts, costs, and timelines. The best sellers convert inspections into cooperative problem-solving, not emotional bargaining.
When to walk away
If a buyer uses inspection findings to demand an unreasonable discount that destroys your net proceeds, you can refuse. If they cancel properly within the inspection condition, they are legally entitled to do so. Plan for the possibility and have your Realtor prepare an immediate relist strategy.
Example negotiation scenario (numbers)
- Sale price: $800,000
- Inspection finds: partial roof wear (est. replacement $12,000) and minor electrical updates ($2,000)
Options:
- Fix both: cost $14,000 — seller pays and keeps sale.
- Offer credit: $10,000 credit to buyer — cheaper than fixing and avoids delays.
- Refuse and hold firm: risk buyer cancelling or demanding a larger cut. If market soft, refusing could cost you the sale.
Choose based on net proceeds, timeline, and market heat.
Practical checklist for sellers right after an inspection
- Read report and highlight urgent items.
- Get at least one licensed contractor quote for any item > $1,000.
- Decide fix vs credit vs decline.
- Draft and send a clear counter-offer through your Realtor with a short response deadline.
- Prepare proof (quotes, invoices, permits) for buyer if you choose to repair.
- Keep your lawyer in the loop for major items.
Final practical advice
Move fast. Keep communication written. Use objective evidence. Offer focused solutions instead of blanket concessions. That’s how sellers in Georgetown keep their sale on track and preserve equity.
Need help negotiating after an inspection?
For direct, local help in Georgetown and Halton Hills contact Tony Sousa — experienced Realtor who knows how inspections play out in this market.
Email: tony@sousasells.ca
Phone: 416-477-2620
Website: https://www.sousasells.ca
FAQ — Common buyer and seller questions about negotiating after a home inspection (Georgetown, ON)
Q: Can a buyer cancel after an inspection?
A: Yes, if the Agreement of Purchase and Sale included an inspection condition and the buyer exercises it properly within the condition deadline. The buyer must notify you by the deadline or waive the condition.
Q: Can a seller force a buyer to accept a counter-offer?
A: No. A counter-offer needs buyer acceptance. If rejected, the buyer can cancel if they had inspection rights, or proceed according to the contract.
Q: Who pays for repairs?
A: Negotiable. Sellers often pay for safety or major items, or offer credits. It depends on cost, market strength, and strategy.
Q: What’s better: fix issues or give a credit?
A: Small, clear fixes are worth doing. Credits simplify processes when repairs are costly or scheduling is tight. Choose based on cost, impact, and closing timeline.
Q: Do I need permits for repairs?
A: Some repairs need permits in Ontario (e.g., structural changes, major electrical/plumbing). Use licensed contractors and get permits if required.
Q: How long does negotiation after inspection take?
A: Typically 24–72 hours for initial responses. Complex items can extend timelines. Use short deadlines to keep momentum.
Q: Should I involve my lawyer?
A: Yes for major structural issues, disputes, or when large credits/price adjustments are proposed. Your lawyer protects your legal and financial interests.
Q: How do local market conditions affect negotiation?
A: In a seller’s market you have more leverage to refuse large concessions. In a buyer’s market you may need to concede more. Georgetown’s market varies—local Realtor guidance matters.
Q: What documentation should I keep?
A: Keep inspection report copies, contractor quotes, receipts, permits, and written communications. These protect you if disputes arise.
Q: What if the buyer requests an expensive fix I can’t afford?
A: Consider a credit, a negotiated shared cost, or a price reduction. Or accept the buyer’s cancellation and relist if needed.
Contact for local expertise and fast action:
Tony Sousa — Realtor, Georgetown & Halton Hills
Email: tony@sousasells.ca | Phone: 416-477-2620 | https://www.sousasells.ca
If you want a pre-inspection strategy, repair estimate contacts, or a negotiation script tailored to your listing, reach out now.
